Laura Darkstar

Reverse Engineering Google’s Local Search Algorithm

Andrew Shotland with LocalSEOGuide, Keynote Speaker at Rocks Digital Marketing Conference

There was a lot of discussion at the conference about Google’s local search algorithm. Andrew Shotland and his team took a unique approach and attempted to reverse engineer the algorithms.  They were on a quest for the Perfect Local SEO Ranking Factors!

They analyzed a number of different factors: Links, Google My Business Listing, Website and Off-Site Local. The data points were put together via repeated Google searches based on keyword and geographic location (city). They partnered with PlacesScout and also used data from Moz and Majestic.

They looked at ~3,000 local searches, ~30,000 Google My Business listings, websites, link, and citations profiles which gave them over a million quantitative data points to analyze. Then they applied two statistical methods which were employed to properly correlate the data. One was to analyze ordinal variables (continuous or integer independent variables) and the other was used for categorical independent variables.

The Ordinal Variables Were Things Like

  • Total customer reviews
  • Followers
  • Average rank of citations
  • Total mentions
  • Authority of citations
  • Links (and there were a number of factors related to links that were explored)

It turns out that the Organic Algorithm outweighed the Local Algorithm. Links are the key to ranking. Websites matter a LOT!

“As the Internet and our understanding of the Internet have grown in complexity, the Toolbar Page Rank score has become less useful to users as a single isolated metric.”

Key piece of advice – Meta Keyword Tags are NOT important (anyone who says this is important should be summarily ignored!)

Local Search Algorithm Drivers

So, in your pursuit of the magical (unicorn) algorithm, where do you focus your efforts?

  1. Links
  2. Website
  3. Google My Business Listing
  4. Off-Site Local (Citations)

Have Andrew and his team completely “cracked the code” yet? Not QUITE… but they’re getting close. What is clear is that links dominated the quantitative analysis of local SEO ranking factors. If you are not focused on and investing in building links and your website, you’re not focused on and investing in the right things.  Yes, Google My Business listings and Citations (and ‘traditional SEO’) do have a place in your strategy, but they should not be your primary focus. And, given the data from this study, it seems like Google is working to expand the scope of what it takes to rank in local search.

Honestly, a blog post doesn’t really do this topic justice. I urge you to check out the slidedeck below.

Don’t forget to read more here and get a more complete picture of what’s going on with the local search algorithm. And realize that it’s going to keep changing and evolving, so be sure to keep up on what Andrew and his team are doing to keep you in the loop!

Laura Darkstar

Laura Darkstar, owner of Adminderella, is an Administrative Strategist, Blogger, Entrepreneur & Aspiring Novelist. She loves social media and small biz owners.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:

Download Our SEO Guide

Created in a joint partnership with Advice Local, this guide — What You Need to Know About SEO — provides an introduction to SEO concepts, strategies and best practices for optimizing a website. Complete the form below and get instant access.


    Web Design & Development

    Your website needs to be aesthetically pleasing and functional. We build websites for desktop and mobile that are both.


    Your website needs to attract search engines and consumers. We are experts in local search and SEO, and can make that happen.


    Anybody can write words on a page, but can they write content that integrates SEO best practices and converts? We can.

    Here’s What our CLIENTs have to say

    [RICH_REVIEWS_SHOW num="all"]

    Their Local Business Websites Rock

    Rocks Digital knows how to build local business websites that convert prospects to customers. Not only do I recommend them to work on my reputation management client’s websites, but they work on the Reputation Sensei brand, too.
    - Chris Snellgrove

    They Customize Their Solutions

    Rocks Digital customizes to meet their client’s needs. We needed our existing website optimized for search. We are now placing for more industry keywords and continue to improve. They consult with our in-house team on content optimization, manage our GMB listing & more.
    - Greta Valenti

    Highly Recommend

    Rocks Digital manages not only the Association of Directory Publishers website, but our Trusted Local Directory. From helping us get our event information on the website to producing guides, blogs and new content, they have what it takes.
    - Cindi Aldrich



    Is your Google My Business listing helping or hurting you? Is bad data causing consumers and search engines to lose trust in your business? This is information you simply must know.

    To get these answers right now, just enter your business name below to run our FREE
    visibility report.

    Need a facelift
    for your website? More search traffic? Need to blog, but don’t have time?

    Our Digital Services Could Be For You